Methodology
How Luminelle scores.
A Luminelle score is a regulatory-scrutiny score, not a safety verdict. It answers one question: how much of what is on this label do regulators restrict, and how much of that restriction can be read off the label itself? It says nothing about whether a product works, and it is not medical advice.
This page is the whole method. The same reasons and the same points appear against every ingredient inside the app, so anything you read here can be checked on any product you scan.
Try the method on any ingredient list with the free ingredient checker.
The short version
- Every ingredient is matched to the regulators' own entries, and each entry is read for what it actually says about this kind of product.
- Each ingredient lands in exactly one of three tiers: a finding, something under scrutiny, or listed but not scored.
- A product starts at 100 and loses points per tier. Repeated small flags saturate, so ten preservatives do not read like a ban.
- The label's own order is used as evidence. EU law orders ingredients by weight only above 1%, and Luminelle uses that line to prove that capped ingredients sit within their cap.
- Products that stay on the skin are scored harder than products that are rinsed off.
Why not simply flag every restricted ingredient
Most scanners score presence: if an ingredient appears on any list, the product loses points. That makes mainstream, fully compliant products score badly on preservatives and UV filters the EU explicitly permits, and it treats a limit on how much may be used as if it were a ban. The criticism levelled at this approach is fair. A limit is not a hazard, and a label cannot show a concentration.
Luminelle's answer is to score what the entry means rather than the fact that an entry exists. A ban is a finding whatever the dose. A concentration limit is scrutiny, because the label cannot prove the level used. And a limit the label can prove, through ingredient order, is not scored at all.
Tier one: findings
Dose-independent. These are the only reasons a product can be called out for something banned, and each costs the points shown, per ingredient.
| Reason shown in the app | Points |
|---|---|
| Banned in cosmetics (EU Annex II, or a California ban already in force, which includes its ban on PFAS). | 20 |
| Banned, with an exception this label gives no reason to apply. | 20 |
| Banned for this kind of product. | 20 |
| The EU chemicals agency concluded it is an endocrine disruptor. | 20 |
| Permitted only in other kinds of product. | 12 |
Tier two: scrutiny
Real restrictions whose weight depends on something the label cannot show: the concentration used, or an assessment that has not concluded. Classes marked as saturating follow a curve rather than a straight sum, so the first flag of a kind costs the most and the tenth costs almost nothing. For a product that stays on the skin, every scrutiny total is multiplied by 1.4.
| Reason shown in the app | Points |
|---|---|
| Banned when used as a fragrance ingredient. | 10 |
| A ban has been passed but is not yet in force. | 10 |
| Under assessment by the EU chemicals agency as a possible endocrine disruptor. | 8 |
| Listed under California Proposition 65. | 6 |
| Permitted up to a limit for this kind of product. The label cannot show the level used. | 4, saturating at 30 |
| Restricted in the EU, with no limit text on the register entry. | 3, saturating at 8 |
| Permitted up to a limit, and listed after ingredients that are usually under 1%. | 2, saturating at 15 |
| A fragrance allergen, named on the label because EU law requires it. | 2, saturating at 14 |
The saturating curve is cap × (1 − e−n/k), where n is the number of ingredients in the class and k is 4 for concentration limits, 5 for fragrance allergens and 2 for other restrictions. Two capped ingredients cost about 12 points; six cost about 23; the total can never pass 30.
The leave-on multiplier is deliberately timid. The EU's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety assumes roughly a hundredfold difference in retention between a product left on the skin and one rinsed off. Luminelle applies 1.4.
Tier three: listed, not scored
Shown against the ingredient so that nothing is hidden, but worth zero points, because the entry does not apply to this product as labelled.
- Permitted up to a limit, and listed after the 1% line, so the label itself shows it is within the limit.
- Regulated for this kind of product, but the condition is not a limit on how much can be used.
- The ban is on a contaminated grade of the material. Cosmetic grade is the grade that passes.
- The ban is on the nano form. A nano ingredient must say [nano] on the label, and this one does not.
- The ban is on material of human origin. Cosmetic supply is animal or plant.
- The register itself says the entry applies only under a condition the label cannot show.
- A purity rule on the raw material, not a limit on the product.
- Restricted for a specific use, such as hair dye, that this product is not.
- Assessed by the EU chemicals agency and concluded not to be an endocrine disruptor.
- A permitted colourant on the EU list, with no limit attached.
- Listed by an industrial or disclosure database only. Not a cosmetic restriction.
When the EU chemicals agency has assessed a substance and concluded it is not an endocrine disruptor, that conclusion stands over any other list that still names it. It is not scored, and it carries no endocrine-disruptor badge.
PFAS
PFAS, the “forever chemicals”, are scored as a ban. California has banned PFAS added to cosmetics since 1 January 2025, and defines them as fluorinated organic chemicals with at least one fully fluorinated carbon atom. Luminelle treats an ingredient as a PFAS when the US EPA's PFAS list names it, or when its own name shows a perfluorinated chain or a fluoropolymer: perfluorodecalin, PTFE, C9-15 fluoroalcohol phosphate.
The fluoride in toothpaste, the synthetic fluorphlogopite in make-up and fluorescent brighteners are not PFAS and are not matched. Ingredients with a single small fluorinated group, such as trifluoropropyl dimethicone, are counted only when the EPA list names them, because a name alone does not settle it.
A ban is recorded against an ingredient's registry number. Some fluorinated silicones have none on file. Those carry the PFAS badge in the app but are not in the score, and the app says so on the ingredient.
Fragrance allergens
EU law names 81 fragrance allergens that must appear individually on the ingredient list. There were 24 until Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 added the rest, among them menthol, vanillin, camphor and the oils of lavender, lemon and rose. Products that do not follow the longer list may be placed on the EU market until 31 July 2026 and sold until 31 July 2028. Luminelle reads all 81 from the regulation's own table. Where an entry also sets a percentage limit, the limit is what is scored.
The score
Each ingredient counts once, in its most severe class. The class totals are added, the scrutiny totals are scaled for leave-on products, and the result is subtracted from 100. The score is clamped to 0 to 100. The per-ingredient points shown in the app are whole numbers that add up to exactly the penalty, so the ledger always reconciles with the score.
The 1% line
Article 19 of Regulation 1223/2009 requires ingredients to be listed in descending order of weight, but only down to 1%. Below that, any order is allowed. Luminelle turns this into evidence. The first ingredient whose legal limit for this kind of product is 1% or lower marks the start of the sub-1% zone. Anything capped at 1% or more that appears after that marker is proven within its limit by the label alone, and is moved to the not-scored tier.
A softer line uses ingredients that are conventionally formulated under 1%, such as EDTA salts, gums, pH adjusters, tocopherol and the named fragrance allergens. A cap proven only against one of these is not a legal fact, so it halves the penalty instead of removing it.
Product type
Many register entries carry different limits for rinse-off, leave-on, oral, nail, deodorant, hair, lip, eye or hand products. Luminelle infers the product type from its category and name, then reads the sub-entry that applies. An entry written for a use this product is not, such as hair dye, is not scored. If a product's type cannot be told, it is treated as leave-on, which is the stricter reading. An entry that is ambiguous for a type is never counted as a violation.
A worked example
CeraVe Foaming Cleanser for Normal to Oily Skin, 236 ml (EAN 3337875597197). Eighteen ingredients resolve to regulator entries. Four carry a flag.
- Sodium benzoate, eighth on the label. EU Annex V/1 permits it in rinse-off products up to 2.5%. The label cannot show the level used, so it is scrutiny, under a concentration limit.
- Phenoxyethanol, twelfth. Annex V/29 permits it up to 1%. This is the first ingredient capped at 1% or lower, so it marks the 1% line. It is itself under a concentration limit.
- Tetrasodium EDTA and ethylhexylglycerin appear only on ECHA's industrial classification inventory. Listed, not scored.
Two ingredients in the concentration-limit class: 30 × (1 − e−2/4) is 11.8 points. A cleanser is rinsed off, so no multiplier. The score is 100 − 11.8, which rounds to 88. Nothing banned, two things under scrutiny, two things listed for transparency.
What a product is for
Beside the score, and never part of it, Luminelle reads each label against three skin issues: sun protection, breakouts and dry skin. It says what a regulator recognises an ingredient for, or what trials found, and what the label shows about how much of that ingredient there is.
The reading is words, not a number. A product either has an ingredient a regulator recognises, placed where it is usually within the recognised strength; or has one whose amount is low or unknown; or has only ingredients with limited evidence; or has nothing for that issue. None of these means the product works. A label does not show the strength or the formulation, and those matter as much as the ingredient.
How much is read from the 1% line above. A percentage in the product's own name is taken as stated. Otherwise, an ingredient listed after the legal marker is at 1% or less, which the label proves; after the softer marker it is only described as low on the label. One listed ahead of both is usually at 1% or more, which the label does not prove, so it is described by its place on the label and not as an amount. For sun protection the measure is the SPF the product states; the ingredient list only shows which permitted UV filters are in it, and cannot show whether the protection is broad spectrum.
Recognition and trial evidence are different things, and the app says both. The FDA lists salicylic acid for acne at 0.5 to 2%, and the Cochrane review found a single trial of it against placebo, with no clear difference at 12 weeks. For breakouts the options with the strongest evidence are medicines: benzoyl peroxide, for one, is allowed in EU cosmetics only in artificial nail products. Luminelle describes the product in front of you and does not recommend a treatment.
An issue is added only where a regulator or good trials give something to cite. Redness is not read, because the evidence there is for prescription medicines. These are the sources behind the three that are.
Sources
Every flag has a primary source, and every ingredient page in the app links to the original entry. These are the lists, what each one does in the score, and how often Luminelle refreshes it.
| Source | Role | Refresh |
|---|---|---|
| EU CosIng (Annexes II to VI) | Bans, restrictions, concentration limits, product-type conditions, permitted colourants and preservatives. | Monthly |
| Regulation (EC) 1223/2009 | The legal text behind CosIng, including Article 19 labelling rules. | Quarterly |
| ECHA endocrine disruptor assessment list | Concluded and pending assessments. Only a concluded endocrine disruptor is a finding. | Quarterly |
| SCCS opinions | Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety opinions, cited on ingredient pages. Not scored. | Monthly |
| ECHA classification and labelling inventory | Industrial hazard classifications. Shown for transparency, never scored. | Quarterly |
| California AB 2762 and AB 2771 | Cosmetic ingredient bans in force since 1 January 2025: 24 named substances, and PFAS as a class. Scored as bans. | Monthly |
| California AB 496 | Bans effective 1 January 2027. Scored as upcoming until then. | Fixed text |
| California OEHHA Proposition 65 | Chemicals known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive harm. | Monthly |
| California CDPH Safe Cosmetics Program | Reported ingredients and the reportable ingredient list. Shown, not scored. | Weekly and monthly |
| US EPA PFAS master list | Identifies which cosmetic ingredients are PFAS, for California’s ban and for the PFAS preference. | Quarterly |
| Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 | The 81 fragrance allergens that must be named on the ingredient list. | Fixed text |
Product names and ingredient lists are a separate matter from the rules they are scored against. They come from Open Beauty Facts and Open Food Facts contributors, under the Open Database Licence, from INCI Beauty and EAN-DB, and from labels people scan or submit in Luminelle.
What the score does not do
It does not estimate exposure, and it does not know the concentration used unless the label proves it. It does not score ingredient quality, efficacy, texture, price or ethics; what a product is for is read separately, above, and takes no points on or off. It does not use hazard classifications written for factories and transport. And it never says an ingredient is toxic or dangerous. The words used are the regulators' own: banned, restricted, permitted up to a limit, under assessment.
Changes
- App version 1.3.0
Products are also read for what they are for: sun protection, breakouts and dry skin, each with its sources. This sits beside the score and never changes it. - App version 1.3.0
PFAS are scored as a California ban, and recognised by name as well as from the EPA list. Before, they were pointed out only to people who asked. - App version 1.3.0
The fragrance allergens named on a label are read from the EU’s full list of 81, up from 26 names. Entries that are not fragrance allergens, such as peanut oil and hydrolysed wheat protein, are no longer described as one. - App version 1.3.0
A substance the EU chemicals agency assessed and cleared of endocrine disruption is no longer scored as “under assessment” because another list still names it. - App version 1.3.0
California AB 2762 is read from the code section itself: all 24 substances, including the 13 PFAS it names.
Corrections
If you think an ingredient is classified wrongly, or an entry is missing, write to info@luminelle.ai with the regulator citation. Corrections are applied at the next source refresh.